| Year | Female Athlete | High School | Male Athlete | High School |
| 1989 | Molly McClimon | Madison Edgewood | Bryant Schultz | Waukesha North |
| 1990 | Julie Beck | Tomah | Bryan Jones | Nicolet |
| 1991 | Lisa Junck | Madison Edgewood | Tom Burger | Milwaukee Lutheran |
| 1992 | Heather Hyland | Nekoosa | Andy Bosley | Homestead |
| 1993 | Heather Hyland | Nekoosa | Sean Agger | LaCrosse Central |
| 1994 | Brittany Rusch | Wausau East | Brendan O'Brien | Rhinelander |
| 1995 | Lisa Kincaid | Palmyra-Eagle | Ray Neosh | Green Bay East |
| 1996 | Stephanie Pesch | Catholic Memorial | Gabe Jennings | Madison East |
| 1997 | Hillary Hyland | Nekoosa | Michael Bennett | Milwaukee Tech |
| 1998 | Hillary Hyland | Nekoosa | B.J. Tucker | Nicolet |
| 1999 | Jill Pedretti | Verona | B.J. Tucker | Nicolet |
| 2000 | Brooke Novak | Kaukauna | Andrew Rock | Stratford |
| 2001 | Brooke Novak | Kaukauna | Marques Johnson | Milwaukee Vincent |
| 2002 | Melissa Talbot | Freedom | Chris Solinsky | Stevens Point |
| 2003 | Brittany Grayson | Catholic Memorial | Chris Solinsky | Stevens Point |
| 2004 | Joanna Schultz | Holmen | Antonio Freeman | Wauwatosa West |
| 2005 | Jenny Soceka | Madison Memorial | Steve Marcelle | Green Bay Preble |
| 2006 | Joanna Schultz | Holmen | David Pede | Wisconsin Lutheran |
| 2007 | Hannah Gronning | Shell Lake | Paul Annear | Richland Center |
| 2008 | Megan Rennhack | Dodgeland | Centrell Minter | Milwaukee Vincent |
| 2009 | Tasha Allen | Milwaukee North | Jared Abbrederis | Wautoma |
| 2010 | Dezerea Bryant | Milw Brad Tech | Matt Widule | Menomonee Falls |
| 2011 | Dezerea Bryant | Milw Brad Tech | Russell Sandvold | Hartland Arrowhead |
| 2012 | Molly Seidel | Univ. Lake School | Carl Hirsch | Brookfield |
| 2013 | Kennedy Blahnik | Algoma | Jake Wallenfang | Green Bay Preble |
| 2014 | Bonnie Draxler | Wrightstown | Ethan Moehn | Monroe |
| 2015 | Gabby Beauvais | Monona Grove | Collin Hofacker | Freedom |
| 2016 | Brooke Jaworski | Wausau West | Josh Pillath | Coleman |
| 2017 | Camille Davre | Whitefish Bay | Cordell Tinch | Bay Port |
